The Tree E-book by Dorling Kindersley, 2022. Dorling Kindersley.
Last yr – 2022 – was a fantastic yr for books about timber. We had Paul Smith’s Timber [reviewed here], Peter Thomas’ Timber [sadly, my requests for a review copy of this title have gone unanswered, so I can’t tell you what I think about that tome…], and The Tree E-book by Dorling Kindersley [which title is here appraised].
Primarily objective
The Tree E-book has 300 pages of elementary textual content material unfold over three Chapters: How timber work, Non-flowering timber [i.e. gymnosperms], and Flowering timber [the angiosperms] (which is crucial chapter – about two-thirds of the e e book). No sources are indicated anyplace for the acknowledged data, and there’s no indication of any further finding out. The e e book concludes with a Glossary (approx. two 4-columned pages, from ‘Alternate’ to ‘Whorl’), an Index (10, 4-columned pages, from ‘Abies sp.’ to ‘zoophily’) [based on a count of the listing of scientific names, 269 taxa are mentioned in the book], and Acknowledgements [in which we learn that ‘additional text’ was supplied by Richard Gilbert and Sarah MacLeod].
Chapter 1
In approx. 30 pages this chapter makes an try to stipulate how timber developed, and the place and the way in which they reside. Curiously, this half states that there are two types of vegetation, herbs, and shrubs; a tree is subsequently solely a large shrub. Whereas it’s acknowledged as not being in all probability probably the most scientifically robust or defensible definition of a tree, it serves its goal. This chapter offers a reasonably good summary of tree biology and ecology. Importantly, and acknowledging that a variety of tree species occur collectively (and with completely different species of residing points), we have got a consideration of how forests work, adopted by separate sections for 4 types of forests – tropical, seasonal tropical, temperate broadleaved, and coniferous. Chapter 1 ends with a 2-page unfold with important particulars about Timber and the setting.
Chapters 2 and three
After the ‘science’ in Chapter 1, Chapters 2 and three think about the ‘tales’, and ‘historic previous’ (and further) of the timber in 90 separate ‘essays’. Each of these things has a formulaic format – at first anyway. The entry is headed up with the plant’s frequent title in English, with the scientific title beneath (and appropriately italicised). Someplace on that first net web page can be a area that has the subsequent sections: Group [cycads, ginkgoes, conifers, magnoliids, monocots, or eudicots]; Family [e.g. Ginkgoaceae, Pinaceae, Betulaceae, Fagaceae…]; Prime [presumably of the above-ground portion]; and Unfold [I’m guessing this is diameter of the crown rather than the underground root system]. Counting on the species, a combination of the subsequent moreover operate: Leaf (or Leaves); Bark; Cone (if a non-flowering tree, or West Indies mahogany); Flower(s) (if a flowering tree); Fruit(s); Catkin (for walnut); and/or Seed. An enthralling miniature picture reveals the aerial part of the tree in outline. For evergreen species (lots of the gymnosperms and some angiosperms similar to pink mangrove and bitter orange), the outlined tree is confirmed completely leaved; for deciduous species (similar to gingko, Japanese larch, and almost the entire angiosperms), one half is confirmed in leaf, the other as a leaf-free silhouette.
The essays begin with queen sago (Cycas circinalis), and end with pink mangrove (Rhizophora mangle) [although the final two pages of Chapter 3 [Flowering trees] is a double-page unfold of photographs of swamp cypress (Taxodium distichum), a non-flowering tree]. Timber showcased embrace: ginkgo; kauri; coast redwood; bristlecone pine; magnolia; cinnamon (and nutmeg, nevertheless not cloves…); coconut palm (and date palm); paper birch; sugar maple; horse chestnut (and sweet chestnut); olive; cacao; frankincense (nevertheless not myrrh); tea (and occasional); white mulberry; sacred fig; rainbow eucalyptus [is there a tree with more-beautiful bark?]; cashew (and Brazil and macadamia nuts, nevertheless not pistachio); mango; neem; teak; mahogany; cinchona; rubber tree; and bitter orange.
The scale of each entry varies from a single net web page (e.g. kapok, and customary lime), to 2 pages (e.g. Italian cypress, and incense cedar), three pages (e.g. Japanese larch), 4 pages (e.g. English yew, and customary juniper), and 6 pages for such timber as Japanese cherry, English oak, and African baobab. All essays are an necessary combination of illustrations (usually in full colour), textual content material (which includes regular narrative and highlighted quotes), and white home.
Primarily subjective…
The Tree E-book is a well-written and beautiful e e book, with many attractive photographs of timber, tree components, and merchandise. In precise reality, there are so many arresting photographs gathered in a single place that one may – just about! – be forgiven for being pretty blasé in regards to the awesomeness and majesty of its materials. Nevertheless the photographs are magnificent, and a particular favourite of mine was the two-page {{photograph}} of the avenue of baobabs on pp. 98/9. The e e book moreover has some good graphics – notably How timber developed [which neatly uses a tree ring analogy to illustrate the course of evolution of tree groups], and Using timber [a summary of how humankind has used trees throughout the ages, from approx. 1 million years ago with evidence of fire in a cave in South Africa [presumably this is a reference to Wonderwerk Cave in the Kalahari Desert (Matt Kaplan, Nature (2012); https://doi.org/10.1038/nature.2012.10372)], to 2019 and the ‘plyscraper’ setting up in Norway]. Although one ought to question how lifelike is the diagram of a vascular bundle on p. 18. For nearly the entire footage one has a approach of scale because of the scale of the tree is indicated within the normal area for each entry. Nonetheless, some indication of measurement might be useful for the photomicrograph of elm stem (p. 18).
Inside the acute constraints of solely 30 or so pages, Chapter 1 delivers a fantastic overview of the ultimate biology and ecology of timber. In reference to the How Forests Work half – a extremely ecological contribution, every Suzanne Simard and the wood-wide web (Robert Macfarlane) (although confirmed as unhyphenated picket large web proper right here, on p. 28) is talked about. Regarding the latter, we’re knowledgeable that “chemical and perhaps electrical indicators is perhaps despatched by way of the neighborhood. Consequently , a tree can recognise its private offspring and ship nutritional vitamins to help their progress” (p. 28). Nonetheless, and reasonably unusually, the time interval ‘picket large web’ simply is not present inside the Index or the Glossary. It’s just about as if the writers/author wanted to acknowledge the existence of this phenomenon, nevertheless to not be seen to publicise or promote it (which, in view of the analysis of this phenomenonn by Justine Karst et al. (Nat Ecol Evol (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-023-01986-1) might very nicely be a wise switch…).
The Tree E-book is an unashamed celebration of timber. Nevertheless, with just some hundred pages it’s inevitable that numerous that fascinating story – notably the historic and cultural relationships between people and timber – might have been omitted. And deciding what to include and what to depart out might want to have been a tricky decision to make. Nonetheless, one important element of how people have exploited vegetation – and notably the walnut tree – simply is not present. Correctly, the e e book doesn’t repeat the age-old ‘advice’ that “a woman, a canine, and a walnut tree, the additional you beat them the upper they be”. Nevertheless, it has missed an opportunity to teach its readers in regards to the Doctrine of Signatures (Bradley Bennett). That historic notion postulates that vegetation resemble the physique components they’re purported to cope with. Certainly one of many fundamental examples of this concept is the similarity of walnut (the fruit and seed) to the human skull, and thoughts, respectively. This was interpreted as a sign that these walnut components are useful for treating sicknesses regarding the head. Furthermore, with “merely over 60,000 species of timber worldwide” (p. 14)*, how have been the handful included inside the e e book chosen? We aren’t knowledgeable. That is the place a standard introduction to the e e book – which isn’t there – might need been useful. All one can conclude is that the highlighted species have a variety of relevance to people.
The Tree E-book simply is not solely stuffed with inconceivable photographs, it’s moreover full of fascinating data – not merely botany, however as well as paintings, exploration, etymology, geography, historic previous, meals, custom, and plenty of others. As a visual and informative feast, one can happily wile away many hours merely admiring the e e book’s photographs or dipping into its pages and following-up some attention-grabbing tree-based titbit or one different. And, with so many data packed into the e e book, it’s an necessary provide of information and inspiration for these of us who focus on or write about timber and different individuals. For example, having these days study Hortus curious by Michael Perry, and learnt relatively so much in regards to the terribly venomous gympie-gympie plant (Dendrocnide moroides) (Marina Hurley), level out of the gympie nut tree understandably caught my eye. Having researched gympie nut (Macadamia ternifolia)**, I uncover that it presents no acknowledged hazards, and its seed [the so-called ‘nut’] and oil have an edibility rating of 4 out of 5. Nonetheless, it’s moreover acknowledged – and by no lesser authorities than the alliance of the Macadamia Conservation Perception, the Macadamia Fund, and the Australian Macadamia Society – that the nuts are “intensely bitter, inedible”. Courses learnt from this? Don’t – basically – depend upon frequent names as an indication of a plant’s properties, and study a variety of sources sooner than making a name on edibility of a plant’s components.
And there are heaps further literary devices of curiosity as correctly. For example, these wise phrases: “Information is rather like the baobab tree; no person specific individual can embrace it” (p. 207). This saying captures correctly the reality that this tree has nice girth; the e e book tells us {{that a}} Senegalese specimen – presumably of Adansonia digitata – has a diameter of 28.7 m. All by means of the precept part of the e e book, the timber and their tales – every biology and plant and different individuals factors of each species – are beautifully built-in.
Nonetheless, The Tree E-book wasn’t with out its awkward second, which arose as soon as I acquired right here all through level out of kaffir lime (Citrus hystrix). Every the plant’s scientific title and customary title are confirmed in-text (p. 299) and inside the Index (p. 313). I beforehand highlighted points over the utilization of this particular frequent title in appraising DK’s The science of vegetation: I’d encourage readers to study that merchandise to go looking out out further in regards to the inappropriateness of the descriptor ‘kaffir’.
Let’s hear it for the authors
No authors are named on the quilt of The Tree E-book. Nevertheless, it’d in all probability’t be anonymous, or written by some artificially-intelligent entity similar to ChatGPT (Sally Weale), its content material materials might have been provided by people. Quite than ‘authors’, we’re knowledgeable (on p. 5 in pretty small print) that the subsequent have been contributors to the e e book: Michael Scott OBE; Dr Ross Bayton***; Andrew Mikolajski***; and Keith Rushforth. Furthermore, there have been two Consultants: Chris Clennett, and Fiona Stafford. All of them have backgrounds of relevance to the topic materials of The Tree E-book, which is encouraging. Nonetheless, it might be useful to know what each contributed – or was consulted upon – by the use of the e e book’s content material materials. As a result of the e e book solely has three chapters not lower than one of those – and most undoubtedly all – might want to have been multi-authored. In truth it seems attainable that each of the umpteen separate tree essays or the fully completely different sections beneath How timber work might have been penned by a named specific individual. Or, given the range of issues coated in each specific individual tree story, probably a variety of authors contributed fully completely different components? We don’t know, so we’ll solely thank the employees – and that options Richard Gilbert and Sarah MacLeod [see Mainly objective… section] en masse for producing a really wonderful contribution to the plants-and-people fashion, which one will little doubt be consulting for a couple of years to come back again.
Let’s hear it for the rivals
If we aren’t knowledgeable who wrote what in The Tree E-book, not lower than we ought to be knowledgeable the place the data that’s assembled inside the e e book acquired right here from. Nevertheless, that moreover seems destined to remain a secret. With no sources acknowledged for any of the statements of actuality which could be to be found on just about every net web page of the e e book, the reader has no easy resolution to pursue his/her new-found curiosity in timber by consulting the distinctive sources for what s/he’s study. And, the rightly mildly-sceptical reader [which includes this reviewer] has no likelihood of checking to ensure the data has been packaged for the reader appropriately. And that’s always a shame because of it does undermine any declare that the e e book is taken into account one among actual scholarship. I think about The Tree E-book to be a bit of actual scholarship, nevertheless can’t present it.
Equally, it’s disappointing that there are usually not any ideas of further finding out for readers to take their finding out about timber and different individuals further. Such a listing is relatively so much easier to supply than the detailed cross-referencing of data to sources and might be of good revenue to the readers. Whether or not or not absence of such a listing is a outcomes of the author not wishing to ‘promote’ the publications of rivals, we don’t know. Nevertheless, the goodwill that such a bit may generate seems further important than any industrial concern over slightly little bit of ‘misplaced’ earnings from fewer e e book product sales, and might be a nice philanthropic gesture which will solely be to Dorling Kindersley’s credit score rating in the long run.
Which strikes a chord in my memory…
With its combination of biology and different individuals relevance, The Tree E-book has the hallmarks of a tree title from Reaktion E-book’s Botanical sequence (e.g. palm, ash, and birch). True, The Tree E-book has further science, is much higher, and covers a far greater number of species and plant households in a single publication than thought of one among Reaktion’s botanical books, nevertheless its intimate combination of vegetation and different individuals was every associated and acquainted – which is an environment friendly issue. As its once more cowl states, The Tree E-book combines “science with historic previous, and folklore with custom”. For completeness, completely different books about timber which have a similar breadth of safety are: Jonathan Drori’s Throughout the World in 80 Timber, and Kevin Hobbs & David West’s The Story of Timber. All 5 e e book titles talked about proper right here should be regarded as further finding out. And, as a service to most people, one other tree books I’m fully glad to counsel as additional/further finding out are: Paul Smith’s Timber, Tony Hall’s The Immortal Yew, Mulberry by Peter Coles, and Valerie Trouet’s Tree story.
Summary
Overlooking the absence of sources for any of its content material materials, The Tree E-book by Dorling Kindersley is a wonderful e e book, and an necessary addition to the plants-and-people fashion. What further need I say?
* An outstanding place to start for a provide for this actuality is the BBC Info article by Mark Kniver. Or you might go straight to the peer-reviewed publication by Emily Beech et al. (Journal of Sustainable Forestry 36: 454-489, 2017; doi: 10.1080/10549811.2017.1310049).
** As part of my gympie nut tree evaluation I moreover revisited my gympie-gympie plant researches and now understand the excellence between poisonous and venomous (John Rafferty; Stephanie Root; Tommy Springer).
*** These individuals moreover contributed to Dorling Kindersley’s The Science of Vegetation.
Related